Haylie Duff’s 12-Year Engagement Never Made It Down the Aisle

After 12 years of being engaged, Haylie Duff and Matt Rosenberg are calling it quits — and they never actually made it to the altar. The actress’s ex-fiancé popped the question on April Fool’s Day 2014, but apparently the joke was on their relationship.

At the time, Duff was all smiles about the proposal. She gushed that Rosenberg’s April Fool’s timing was \”genuine and sweet,\” brushing off any concerns that he was just messing with her. But a dozen years later, the pair has decided to go their separate ways without ever walking down the aisle.

The fact that they managed to stay engaged for over a decade without wedding bells is honestly wild. Like, at what point does an engagement just become a relationship status? Duff hasn’t publicly detailed what went wrong or when they decided to split, but clearly something shifted after more than a decade together.

This is the kind of relationship timeline that makes you wonder what was actually going on behind closed doors. Twelve years is a looong time to stay in engagement limbo. Either way, it looks like Duff is moving on from this chapter of her life.