Best Burger Joints in Columbia Missouri
Published April 17, 2024 at 12:52 am
Explore the sizzling, savory world of Columbia, Missouri as we take you on a tour of the city’s top-rated burger havens that are sure to satisfy your cravings for the perfect patty.

Discovering Gourmet Delights: Columbia's Top Burger Spots
Embarking on a culinary expedition for the perfect burger opens a world of mouthwatering possibilities.
In Columbia, Missouri, the quest for a succulent, flavorful burger can lead you down a maze of endless choices.
For food enthusiasts and casual diners alike, there's a wealth of burger joints, but let me guide you to the creme de la creme of this city's offerings.
Booches Billiard Hall: A Rich History with a Delicious Offering
Nestled in the heart of downtown, Booches Billiard Hall isn't just an establishment; it's a time-honored tradition in Columbia.
With a legacy dating back to 1884, this storied spot serves up more than just games of pool and a classic pub atmosphere.
Here, you'll find the crown jewel: a perfectly proportioned burger that's as rich in flavor as the venue's history.
Pros:
- Historic ambiance contributes to an unforgettable dining experience
- Their concise menu ensures every burger is crafted to perfection
Cons:
- The bustling atmosphere might not be everyone's cup of tea
- Limited seating often means a bit of a wait for those juicy patties
Reflecting on the experience of burger aficionados, one cannot ignore the reverence they hold for Booches' thin, crispy-edged patties served unpretentiously on wax paper.
Gazing into the dozens of rave reviews, a common thread emerges: an enduring love for the nostalgic charm and simple, yet unbeatable, classic cheeseburger.
Find This and More on Amazon
Lizzy's: Innovation Between the Buns
In the sphere of burger eateries, Lizzy's occupies a special niche.
This modern joint brings a twist to the classic burger formula with creative toppings and unique sauces.
Whether it's the avocado-crème burger or the spicy peanut butter-infused delight, each option is a journey for your tastebuds.
Amidst flipping through pages of glowing testimonies, diners highlight Lizzy's fresh ingredients and the sophisticated yet accessible fusion flavors.
Pros:
- Daring flavor pairings that stand out in Columbia's burger scene
- Friendly staff who aren't shy about recommending their favorites
Cons:
- May not cater to the purist looking for a traditional burger experience
- During peak hours, service could face slight delays due to the rush
Given the adventurous burger selections, it's no wonder Lizzy's has built a reputation for being the go-to spot when craving something new and exciting.
And remember, if saving money on your motor adventures is on your mind, you might find it interesting to learn about leasing a car with tips to get the best deal.
Shakespeare's Pizza & Pub: Where Pizza Meets Burgers
Known far and wide for their pizza, Shakespeare's Pizza & Pub also throws its hat into Columbia's burger ring.
Surprising to some, their burger selection stands tall with an emphasis on juicy, well-seasoned beef and classic fixings.
Dive into a review pool and you'll swim through consistent praise for their pizza-bun burger – a Shakespeare's signature innovation.
Pros:
- Quality meats cooked to juicy perfection
- The unique pizza burger provides an unexpected yet delightful fusion
Cons:
- Pizza loyalists may overlook the burger menu entirely
- The spot's popularity often means navigating through a lively crowd
The consensus appears clear: while pizzas dominate, their burgers deserve their share of the spotlight for their impeccable taste and ingenious hosting on pizza dough buns.
And in the spirit of solving automotive issues, this spot's central location might remind you about economical solutions for car breakdowns just in case you're on your way to pick up one of these scrumptious burgers and encounter a hiccup with your car.
Five Guys: A Nationwide Favorite Right in Your Backyard
Five Guys, the beloved national chain, also makes its home in Columbia – and for a good reason.
Its laid-back setting and customizable burger options cater to any and all burger desires one might have.
Scanning through customer feedback, it's evident Five Guys has a fanbase for its hearty portions and the freedom to pile on as many toppings as you want without extra cost.
Pros:
- Customizable burgers with a plethora of toppings at no additional charge
- Hefty servings that offer great value for your dollar
Cons:
- As a chain restaurant, it lacks the local charm some diners seek out
- The simplistic setting may not appeal to those looking for a dining 'experience'
While Five Guys might be known for its generously sized burgers, environment-conscious drivers might also seek to size up eco-friendly car colors that could increase resale value, a consideration for those who think green.
True to their reputation, Five Guys in Columbia continues to satisfy with perfectly cooked, juicy burgers that seem to never skimp on flavor or size.
West Main Pizza²: More Than Just Pizza
Although pizza is in the name, West Main Pizza²’s burger offerings are hidden gems waiting to be uncovered.
Pizza places that do burgers well are a rare breed, and this spot delivers on variety and quality.
It's said that people are pleasantly surprised with West Main Pizza²’s foray into the burger world, noting the balanced flavors and satisfying sides that accompany each burger.
Pros:
- Diverse menu including gluten-free options
- Generous portions that satisfy even the heartiest of appetites
Cons:
- Burgers may play second fiddle to pizza, potentially limiting burger-specific innovation
- It's easy to get distracted by the extensive pizza selections
Not only does this spot boast a substantial, well-crafted burger, but the sentiment is shared among reviews that the high-quality ingredients are worth noting.
As you consider heading to West Main Pizza² for a delightful meal, you might be thinking of ways to keep your car pristine. In that case, consider reading up on tips to keep your car rust-free and valuable.
44 Canteen: Where Creativity and Culinary Skills Unite
For those looking for a gourmet twist on the American staple, 44 Canteen proffers an intriguing menu.
This restaurant is the epitome of culinary creativity, blending unusual ingredients that elevate the burger to new heights.
Reviewers often express their appreciation for the quality of meat and the chef-driven concoctions that you'd be hard-pressed to find elsewhere in town.
Pros:
- Inventive burger creations that challenge traditional palates
- Use of locally-sourced ingredients, supporting the community and providing exceptional freshness
Cons:
- Gourmet options may come at a higher price point than a typical burger joint
- Those with simpler tastes might find the flavor combinations too complex
If the mention of high-quality ingredients and innovative dishes has your interest piqued, 44 Canteen is a Columbia destination worth visiting.
A passionate foodie's heart often aligns with the love for the open road, so while indulging in a culinary experience, you might also ponder on 2023’s best value car audio systems for those long drives that call for quality tunes.
The Best of Both Worlds: Gunter Hans Bakery & Cafe
At Gunter Hans Bakery & Cafe, you’ll find a European-inspired approach to burgers that fuses tradition with creative flair.
Here, the burger is not just a meal but an experience, with hand-crafted patties and artisanal bread that complement each other perfectly.
Customers have shared their love for Gunter Hans’ unique harbinger of flavors, attesting to the cafe’s attention to detail and quality ingredients.
Pros:
- Artistic approach to the burger, offering a burst of flavors
- Ambiance that transports you to a European cafe right in Columbia
Cons:
- May not align with a classic burger joint’s expectations
- Prices may be a bit higher due to the gourmet experience
According to the chorus of enthusiasts, Gunter Hans is celebrated for not only its delicious burgers but also for providing a distinctive dining atmosphere that’s unmatched in the city.
And if European elegance has you dreaming of touring in style, you might like to read about affordable fixes for your car’s air conditioning to ensure a cool and comfortable ride to this exceptional culinary spot.
The Under-the-Radar Champion: Dave & Buster’s
Dave & Buster’s, while known as an entertainment hub, also takes a spot on the burger hotlist in Columbia.
It’s a playground not only for games but also for burger lovers seeking something satisfying after a round of arcade fun.
Venturing through various testimonials, the praise for Dave & Buster’s burgers often accompanies fond memories of fun and frolic, making each meal unforgettable.
Pros:
- Enjoyable combo of food and entertainment
- Generous portions that can easily be shared
Cons:
- Some may prefer a quieter, more focused dining ambiance
- Distribution between gaming and dining can sometimes feel overwhelming
The unexpected pleasure derived from the burgers at Dave & Buster’s adds to the attraction of this popular destination. With each bite, guests are often taken aback by the quality presented amidst the arcade’s lights and sounds.
For those looking forward to a trip that’s as entertaining as it is palatable, consider brushing up on your driving safety knowledge, such as reading through tips to avoid costly accidents on rainy days.
Wrap-Up: Columbia’s Burger Landscape
Embarking upon a journey through Columbia’s diverse burger landscape reveals a tapestry of tastes that cater to every preference.
From historic haunts like Booches Billiard Hall to innovative spots like Lizzy’s, you’ll be spoiled for choice in your pursuit of the perfect patty. Each location not only feeds your hunger but also enriches your experience of the culture and community within Columbia.
So next time you’re cruising through town, yearning for a bite of comfort tucked between two buns, remember these favorites. Each has won the hearts of locals and visitors alike, proving that while tastes may vary, the love for a good burger is a universal truth.
And remember, a true burger journey goes beyond the plate—it’s about the vibrant life of a city that surrounds it. Whether you’re a car enthusiast or simply a lover of good food, tips like those found in guides on how future tech can save you money in your car might just enhance your culinary adventures on the road to Columbia’s best burger joints.

Avery Ingram
Contributor