St. Louis’s Best Pizza Places
Published April 9, 2024 at 2:42 pm
Discover the sensational flavors of St. Louis as we take you on a culinary journey through the city’s top-rated pizza places, each offering a slice of heaven for every type of pizza lover.

Discovering St. Louis’s Pizza Scene
When you think of St. Louis, you might think of the iconic Gateway Arch, blues music, or maybe even their storied baseball tradition.
But there’s another hidden gem in this bustling Midwest city: the pizza.
Yes, St. Louis has its own unique take on the Italian staple that any pizza aficionado should try.
Let’s dive deep into the cheesy, saucy world of St. Louis’s best pizza places.
Finding the Perfect Crust
One of the most distinctive features of St. Louis pizza is the crust.
It’s thin, it’s crispy, and it has a cracker-like consistency that sets it apart from other styles.
If you’re all about the crust, one spot you’ll want to check out is Imo’s Pizza, famous for pioneering the St. Louis style pizza.
Their secret? A combination of yeast-less dough and cutting-edge ovens that perfectly crisp every pizza.
The Magic of Provel Cheese
What would a St. Louis pizza be without the creamy, dreamy Provel cheese?
This unique blend of cheddar, Swiss, and provolone cheeses was made for melting, and it’s a St. Louis tradition found nowhere else.
A visit to Joey B’s on the Hill offers an authentic taste of this local delicacy.
Reviewers rave about the gooey goodness that perfectly complements their rich tomato sauce.
Traditional Meets Trendy
But St. Louis’s pizza scene isn’t just about sticking to tradition.
Places like Pi Pizzeria blend that iconic St. Louis style with new, innovative toppings.
You might be surprised to find figs, fresh goat cheese, and even wild boar sausage gracing your pizza.
And with Pi’s commitment to using local, sustainable ingredients, you can feel good about what you’re eating.
The City’s Best Kept Secrets
Off the beaten path, you’ll find hidden gems like Blackthorn Pub and Pizza.
Located in the Penrose neighborhood, their deep-dish Chicago-style pizza has St. Louis residents and visitors hooked.
Their slightly sweet sauce on top of the cheese sets it apart from your typical pizza joint.
Plus, their relaxed pub atmosphere makes for a perfect casual pizza night.
Family-Friendly Pizza Spots
For those with little ones in tow, places like Dewey’s Pizza offer a family-friendly environment.
Children love watching the open kitchen where dough is tossed high into the air by skilled pizza makers.
And Dewey’s is not just for families – their craft beer selection makes it an appealing destination for adults too.
Each location radiates a vibrant community feel, which speaks to its popularity among locals.
Savor Slice after Slice
For the pizza lover who can’t just stop at one slice, there’s The Slice House by PW Pizza.
Their pizzas are made to order, ensuring every bite is as fresh as it can be.
But if you can’t decide, you may find yourself enjoying a whole pie – it’s just that irresistible.
Just be sure to save room for their delightful dessert pizzas, topped with cinnamon streusel or hazelnut chocolate spread.
Gluten-Free and Vegan Options Aplenty
St. Louis’s pizza scene thinks of everyone.
Restaurants like Katie’s Pizza & Pasta Osteria provide a slew of gluten-free and vegan options.
Their cauliflower crust pizza is a hit, topped with fresh, high-quality ingredients that don’t skimp on flavor.
Vegans will appreciate their dedication to creating a cheese alternative that melts perfectly, just like Provel.
Dynamic Duo: Pizza and Brews
Combining craft beer with pizza is a match made in heaven, and St. Louis delivers with spots like Schlafly Bottleworks.
Their freshly baked pizzas are often paired with a signature brew recommended by their knowledgeable staff.
From hoppy IPAs to rich stouts, there’s a beer to complement every savory slice.
Plus, their use of locally sourced toppings showcases the best of Missouri’s produce.
Exploring the Neapolitan Influence
If you’re a fan of the old-world charm of Italian pizza, then St. Louis has you covered with The Good Pie.
This quaint eatery follows the strict guidelines of Neapolitan pizza-making, using a wood-fired oven that reaches scorching temperatures.
It’s not just about the heat; the attention to authentic ingredients like San Marzano tomatoes and buffalo mozzarella earns them top marks.
Plus, the charred and chewy crust they achieve is something of a local legend.
St. Louis’s Take on Pizza-Turned-Dessert
Sweet treats and St. Louis’s inventive pizza culture make a surprisingly delicious pairing.
At Union Loafers, they’ve crafted a dessert pizza that’s a true feast for the senses, with seasonal fruits and a sweet, tender crust.
Think of it as a pizza meets a fruit tart, bridging the gap between meal and dessert in the best possible way.
It’s a testament to the culinary creativity that abounds in St. Louis’s pizza kitchens.
Where the Locals Go
Veterans in the local food scene often have a few favorites up their sleeve that might not be on the tourist trail.
One such spot is Pizzeoli, a cozy, wood-fired pizza joint in the heart of Soulard.
Famed for their sourdough crust and top-notch vegan options, they’ve quickly become a local staple.
And let’s not overlook their robust wine list, offering the perfect complement to their artisanal pies.
Adventurous Toppings and Bold Flavors
Not for the faint of heart, restaurants like Melo’s Pizzeria are pushing the boundaries with their topping selections.
Here you’ll find pizzas adorned with delicacies like truffle oil, spicy honey, and house-made nduja spread.
It’s a treat for those seeking a departure from the classic pizza experience.
And for the curious, they offer a slice of the day, featuring their latest and greatest experiments.
Perfect Pizza Pairings
While exploring these culinary institutions, you might wonder what to drink with your slice of St. Louis heaven.
Fear not, because wine and beer pairings have become an art form at these pizzerias.
At locations like Pastaria, they’ve curated a wine list that complements their pizzas, from rich reds to crisp whites.
They understand that the right beverage can elevate your pizza experience to new heights.
Experience the Pizza Buffet Scene
For those with an appetite that just won’t quit, Cicero’s offers an all-you-can-eat pizza buffet extravaganza.
This family-friendly locale doesn’t just offer quantity; it takes pride in the quality and variety of its selection.
From meat lovers to margherita, the buffet is an excellent way to sample many styles without breaking the bank.
It’s the perfect spot for group dining, where everyone can leave satisfied, no matter their pizza preference.
Artisanal Pizzas with a Cult Following
Craving something gourmet? Then you cannot miss a visit to Fratelli’s Ristorante.
Their hand-tossed, stone-baked pizzas feature bold flavor combinations and perfectly balanced textures.
Fans can’t get enough of their signature smoked salmon pizza with a dill cream sauce.
And their robust customer loyalty is a testament to their enduring culinary craftsmanship.
St. Louis’s Pizza Festivals and Events
Beyond the daily pizza offerings, St. Louis hosts various events celebrating this beloved dish.
Keep an eye out for pizza festivals where you can indulge in slices from the city’s top pizzerias, all in one place.
These events are usually teeming with live music, cooking demonstrations, and of course, endless pizza.
They’re a fantastic opportunity to discover your new favorite pizza spot and mingle with fellow enthusiasts.
Enjoying a Pizza Picnic in the Parks
There’s something special about enjoying a hot slice of pizza in the great outdoors.
Grab a pie to go from your favorite pizzeria and head over to Forest Park or the Missouri Botanical Garden.
Here, under the canopy of trees or beside a tranquil lake, pizza somehow tastes even better.
It’s the perfect way to combine a love for nature with a passion for pizza.
End Your Night with St. Louis Pizza
When the night falls and the bars begin to close, it’s comforting to know that St. Louis’s pizza scene thrives after dark.
Many pizzerias, like Mangia Italiano, stay open late, serving up pies that hit the spot after an evening out.
Their classic and innovative pizzas are a dependable way to satisfy those late-night cravings.
Plus, the vibrant energy of St. Louis’s nightlife is the ideal backdrop to end your day on a delicious note.
“`html
A Guide to St. Louis Pizza for Every Occasion
Whether it’s a casual get-together or a special celebration, the pizza venues in St. Louis cater to every affair.
For example, the elegant atmosphere at Sardella offers a slightly more upscale dining experience, perfect for date nights or family celebrations.
St. Louis Pizza Goes Global
Our pizza palette is not just limited to the traditional or trendy local flavors.
Establishments like A Pizza Story give you slices of the globe, with toppings inspired by international cuisines.
Health-Conscious Choices in the Pizza World
Worrying about healthy options when eating out? Well, St. Louis pizzerias like The U.R.B. (Urban Research Brewery) present healthier pizza alternatives with a variety of vegetable toppings and whole wheat crust options.
Their menu items appeal to health-minded individuals without sacrificing the taste pizza lovers crave.
Late Night Bites: 24-Hour Pizza in St. Louis
And when your pizza craving hits at the oddest hour, fear not, for there’s always a 24-hour spot like Master Pieza waiting to serve you.
They’ve become a haven for those with late-night munchies, proving that good pizza isn’t confined to traditional business hours.
How to Spot Authentic St. Louis Pizza
So, you’re visiting St. Louis and want to ensure you’re trying the real deal.
Authentic St. Louis pizza places will always have the classic characteristics: cracker-thin crust, Provel cheese, and square slices.
Create Your Own St. Louis Pizza Tour
If you’re really passionate about finding the best pizza, why not create your own tour?
Gather friends or family and visit several pizzerias in one day, comparing and contrasting the styles and flavors unique to St. Louis.
Pizza for a Cause: Charitable Pizzerias
Some St. Louis pizzerias, like Square One Brewery & Distillery, also prioritize giving back to the community.
By dining here, you can enjoy a scrumptious pizza while contributing to local charities, making it a meal that tastes good and feels good.
Let’s Talk About St. Louis Pizza Toppings
Toppings can make or break a good pizza, and St. Louis doesn’t shy away from being bold in this department.
From the surprising but delicious addition of pickles at places like Union Loafers to the spicy Volpi salami pizzas at Salume Beddu, there’s a topping for every taste bud out there.
Navigating the Pizza Menu
Looking at a menu full of delicious options can be overwhelming.
But whether you go for the house specials or build your own, each pizza place in St. Louis offers a chance to explore your culinary curiosity.
Get Social, Share a Pizza
There’s nothing quite like sharing a pizza with friends.
Large venue pizzerias with communal tables like Fratelli’s Ristorante are perfect spots for social gatherings and sharing different flavors together.
Taking St. Louis Pizza Home: Delivery and Takeout
In today’s world, convenience is key, and St. Louis pizzerias deliver in that aspect, quite literally.
With many places offering delivery or curbside pickup, enjoying a night in with an exemplary pizza pie has never been easier.
Joining the Craft Movement
St. Louis’s culinary scene, including pizza, is part of the larger craft movement that embraces handmade, artisan techniques.
Visiting places like Pastaria, you can witness the craftspeople at work, tossing and topping what’s soon to be your pizza.
Connecting Through Pizza
Despite our differences, pizza brings people together, acting as a universal language of enjoyment.
Gathering around a table at your favorite St. Louis spot, sharing slices and stories, is what the pizza culture here is all about.
Sustainable Pizza Practices
Not only is St. Louis serving up delicious pies, but they’re also eco-conscious about it.
Pizzerias like Pizzeoli use locally sourced ingredients, supporting the environment and the community.”
Celebrating Pizza Month in St. Louis
Did you know that October is National Pizza Month in the United States?
It’s the perfect occasion to explore the rich variety of pizzas that St. Louis has to offer and to find awesome deals and special menus dedicated to this beloved dish.
Your Pizza, Your Way
At the end of the day, St. Louis knows pizza is personal.
And with the myriad of options available, from the dough to the toppings, you’re sure to find or create your perfect pizza right here in the Gateway to the West.
“`

Avery Ingram
Contributor